The UK Immigration and Asylum Bill has passed its final stage in the House of Commons despite opposition from 14 Labour MPs, giving Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood parliamentary backing to proceed with major changes to the country’s asylum and settlement system.
The legislation secured 290 votes to 94 on Tuesday, a government majority of 196, and will now move to the House of Lords for further examination. LBC reported that the vote came after disagreements within Labour over provisions affecting refugees, migrant workers and people seeking permanent residence in Britain.
Among the Labour MPs who opposed the Bill were Diane Abbott, John McDonnell, Nadia Whittome and Bell Ribeiro-Addy.
The proposed reforms are intended to accelerate the removal of unsuccessful asylum applicants, reduce the initial period of refugee protection and establish an independent immigration appeals authority.
Mahmood has described the package as the “most significant migration reforms of modern times”, arguing that it would close legal loopholes and make the immigration system more effective.

Failed asylum seekers face faster removal process
One of the central provisions of the Bill concerns the removal of people whose asylum applications have been rejected.
Under the proposed changes, immigration officers would no longer be required to provide five working days’ notice before removal procedures begin.
The government believes removing this requirement will help speed up enforcement and reduce delays in returning people who have no legal basis to remain in the country.
The legislation also proposes cutting the initial period of leave granted to refugees from five years to two-and-a-half years.
This would mean refugees would face an earlier review of their immigration status rather than automatically receiving the longer initial period of protection under the existing arrangement.
Independent authority to handle immigration appeals
The Bill also provides for the establishment of an independent immigration appeals authority.
The proposed body is part of the government’s wider attempt to change how immigration decisions are challenged and reviewed.
However, some Labour MPs have expressed concern about the broader implications of the reforms, particularly the proposed settlement arrangements and the possibility of making permanent residence more difficult to obtain.
Ribeiro-Addy criticised the proposals affecting settlement, warning that permanent residence could be “bought and flogged to the highest bidder”.
Government drops controversial settlement proposal
The government has already made concessions following concerns raised by Labour MPs over proposed changes to settlement eligibility.
A plan to increase the waiting period for lower-paid work visa holders seeking permanent residence was dropped earlier in November.
Under the revised arrangement, health and social care visa holders earning at least £25,000 annually will remain eligible for settlement after five years, provided they meet the conditions attached to their visas.
The exemption also covers certain non-degree-level public sector roles in health and education.
However, some Labour MPs argued that the protection should be extended to a wider range of skilled workers.
Labour amendment to widen exemption rejected
Neil Duncan-Jordan, Labour MP for Poole, sought to expand the exemption through an amendment to the legislation.
His proposal was defeated by 368 votes to 44, leaving the government’s narrower exemption in place.
Home Office minister Anna Turley defended the decision, describing the special treatment for care workers and certain public service employees as exceptional.
She said the exemption recognised the contribution these workers made during and after the Covid pandemic.
Turley also argued that Duncan-Jordan’s amendment risked weakening English-language and criminality requirements for people applying for settlement.
The disagreement exposed differences within Labour over how to balance tighter immigration controls with recognition of the contribution made by workers in essential public services.
Fourteen Labour MPs vote against Mahmood’s reforms
Despite securing approval for the Bill, the government faced a rebellion from 14 members of its own parliamentary party.
Abbott, McDonnell, Whittome and Ribeiro-Addy were among those who voted against the legislation at its third reading.
Their opposition reflected concerns about the impact of the proposed measures on refugees, migrant workers and people seeking long-term residence in Britain.
Nevertheless, the government secured a comfortable majority, allowing the legislation to complete its final Commons stage.
The vote means ministers can now defend the proposals before peers in the upper chamber, where further scrutiny and possible amendments are expected.
Conservatives say reforms do not go far enough
The Bill also attracted criticism from opposition parties, although for different reasons.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp described the legislation as “some small steps in the right direction”.
However, he argued that Britain would not achieve full control of its borders without withdrawing from the European Convention on Human Rights.
His comments suggest the Conservatives believe the proposed changes are insufficient to deliver the level of immigration control they want.
During the parliamentary debate, SNP MP Pete Wishart also accused Reform UK MP Sarah Pochin of “quasi-racism” following her contribution on immigration.
The exchanges reflected the wider political divisions surrounding immigration policy in Britain, with disagreements over border enforcement, refugee protection and the country’s international legal obligations.
House of Lords to examine the legislation
Following its approval by 290 votes to 94, the UK Immigration and Asylum Bill will proceed to the House of Lords.
Peers will have the opportunity to examine its provisions, including the proposed faster removal process, the reduction in the initial period of refugee leave and the establishment of the independent appeals authority.
The upper chamber’s scrutiny will be an important stage before the legislation can complete its parliamentary passage.

The government has already adjusted some settlement proposals following objections from Labour MPs, but the Commons rebellion indicates that concerns remain over the final package.
For Mahmood, the vote represents a significant step towards implementing the government’s immigration programme. However, the legislation’s passage through the Commons has not ended the debate over how Britain should manage asylum applications, refugee protection and permanent settlement.