Muslim citizenship fears in India have intensified following reports that people removed from electoral registers are being detained, questioned about their nationality and deported to Bangladesh, even as some affected families present records they say prove generations of Indian ancestry.
The human consequences are illustrated by the case of Sahida Fakir, a 38-year-old mother of two who left her home in Mumbai on July 19 to buy vegetables. She told her younger son she would return shortly, but more than three months later, she was living in a Bangladeshi village, separated from her husband and children.
Fakir told Reuters that plainclothes officers seized her phone and forced her into a vehicle. She said the device contained copies of her identity documents, which could have helped establish her Indian citizenship. Court filings identified the officers as members of the Mumbai police crime branch. The department did not respond to a request for comment.
Her experience forms part of a wider pattern documented by Reuters, which interviewed 10 families whose relatives had faced detention, deportation or questioning over their citizenship after their names disappeared from India’s revised electoral registers.
Electoral revision leaves millions off voter lists
India’s nationwide electoral-register revision removed approximately 130 million names, making it the largest deletion of voters in the country’s history.
Although the exercise was presented as a review of voter records, its consequences have extended into disputes over citizenship and immigration status. Some people excluded from the registers have subsequently faced official inquiries into whether they are Indian nationals.
The distinction between electoral eligibility and citizenship is central to the controversy. Being removed from a voter list does not automatically establish that someone is a foreigner. Yet families interviewed by Reuters said the deletion of names had preceded police action against some of their relatives.
Muslims appear to have been disproportionately affected by the exercise, according to figures cited by the Kolkata-based Sabar Institute. The issue has generated concern among rights advocates, who say India’s Muslim minority has faced increasing discrimination and exclusionary policies since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party came to power in 2014.
West Bengal recorded particularly extensive deletions ahead of its state elections earlier this year. Approximately nine million names were removed in the state.
Of the 2.7 million names deleted after a closer review, Muslims accounted for about 70%, despite making up roughly 27% of West Bengal’s population, according to the Sabar Institute.
The BJP won the election, taking control of the state for the first time. Sabir Ahamed, the institute’s founder, said anti-incumbency had contributed to the result but argued that voter deletions also played a significant part in determining the outcome.
The BJP has denied deliberately targeting legitimate Indian citizens.
Home Minister’s statement intensifies concerns
The relationship between voter verification and immigration enforcement became more controversial after Home Minister Amit Shah addressed a rally in Haryana on November 5.
Shah openly connected the removal of suspected illegal immigrants from electoral registers with the government’s intention to expel them from India.
He said the BJP was determined to identify infiltrators, remove them from voter lists and subsequently locate and deport them individually.
The statement has raised questions about how the two processes are being applied, particularly where people whose names have disappeared from electoral registers insist they are Indian citizens.
For affected families, the concern is that exclusion from the voter list could become a trigger for immigration investigations without a proper determination of nationality.
India’s Home Ministry, Prime Minister’s Office and Election Commission did not respond to Reuters’ requests for comment.
West Bengal has become a major focus of the campaign, particularly among Bengali-speaking Muslims. The sensitivity surrounding citizenship in the state is closely connected to its history and the movement of people across the India-Bangladesh border.
The 1947 partition of British India divided Bengal, separating communities and families. Further migration occurred during the 1971 war that led to Bangladesh’s independence. As a result, some families have relatives and historical connections on both sides of the border.
Deportation case exposes dispute over citizenship evidence
Fakir said she was taken across the border at approximately 1 a.m. through an unfenced and unmanned stretch. She recalled walking through muddy terrain for hours before a farmer found her crying and offered help.
Court documents show that Mumbai police told the court she had been handed over to the Border Security Force along the Assam border before being deported to Bangladesh through designated authorities.
She was among 149 people deported during the operation after officials identified them as Bangladeshi nationals.
Fakir strongly disputes that classification. She maintains that her family has deep roots in India and that authorities did not give her a fair opportunity to present documents supporting her claim.
Her family filed a petition at the Supreme Court in August, arguing that removal from the electoral register could not independently determine citizenship. The petition also challenged her deportation on the grounds that it relied on an untested assertion by executive authorities.
Records examined by Reuters showed that Fakir’s parents and grandparents had appeared on electoral registers in Swarupnagar, West Bengal, dating back to India’s first national election in 1952. Their names were also recorded on the 2002-03 voter lists, which became an important reference point in the latest revision.
Fakir’s own name had appeared on West Bengal’s electoral registers since at least 2008, according to her voter identification document reviewed by Reuters.
However, Mumbai’s Foreigners Regional Registration Office told the Calcutta High Court that Fakir had produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate during an inquiry but failed to provide what officials considered valid or credible documentary evidence of Indian citizenship.
She disputed the account, saying officers had taken her phone, which contained copies of documents she wanted to use in her defence.
She also pointed out that Indian law does not require citizens to carry valid identification documents at all times.
Nasiruddin Sheikh describes weeks in detention
Fakir’s case is not isolated. Another citizenship dispute before the Calcutta High Court involves utensil hawker Nasiruddin Sheikh and four other people who challenged their detention after their names were removed from electoral registers.
The petitioners said they were arrested even though appeals against their deletions were still pending before special tribunals.
Sheikh said he was working in Chhattisgarh, hundreds of kilometres from his home, when police detained him alongside 22 other people.
He said 19 of those detained were released after 14 days when authorities discovered that their names appeared on the revised electoral registers. Sheikh and three others whose names were absent remained in custody for 32 days.
According to Sheikh, a police officer told him that because his name was missing from the voter list, he was Bangladeshi.
He described the detention facility as a large hall with beds for more than 60 people. Detainees underwent medical examinations and biometric registration before being confined.
Sheikh said they were not allowed to go outside, describing the conditions as equivalent to imprisonment.
He and the others were eventually released on the night before their scheduled court hearing.
Police and state lawyers have told the Calcutta High Court that West Bengal has no permanent detention camps.
Nevertheless, Reuters reporters visiting a holding facility for suspected foreign migrants in Murshidabad observed clothes hanging inside the premises and people looking through its windows. An ambulance and a covered police bus were also present inside the heavily guarded compound.
Mosami Ray, a resident living opposite the facility, said she had seen people brought there about two months earlier and relatives crying outside.
Legal challenges mount as families await decisions
The growing number of disputes over electoral-register deletions has created a heavy burden for people seeking legal redress.
Families are challenging the removal of names and attempting to establish the citizenship of relatives who have been detained or deported. Some cases involve individuals who say they possess decades of family and identity records connecting them to India.
Human rights activist Kirity Roy said millions of cases relating to deleted voter names were awaiting justice. He expressed concern about the slow pace of the special tribunals responsible for reviewing appeals.
The delays are particularly worrying for families whose relatives remain caught up in citizenship investigations. For them, the process is not simply about restoring voting rights but also about preventing detention, separation and possible removal from the country.
Fakir’s husband, Jumman, is pursuing legal action while she remains separated from their two children. Her case illustrates how a dispute over an electoral record can have consequences reaching far beyond the ballot box.
The Muslim citizenship fears in India have consequently become part of a wider debate about electoral administration, immigration enforcement, minority rights and the legal safeguards available to people whose nationality is questioned.
Reuters reported that all 10 families it interviewed said their affected relatives had Indian identity or family documents, while other members of their families, including parents and siblings, remained on voter lists.
The authorities have not responded to Reuters’ enquiries about the individual cases. The pending court proceedings may help clarify the legal relationship between electoral-register exclusions and citizenship determinations, as well as the procedures that should apply before anyone is detained or deported.