Manchester United comeback against Roma has offered Michael Carrick temporary relief from mounting pressure, with captain Bruno Fernandes dismissing claims that the players were fighting to preserve their manager’s position.
United produced an impressive recovery at Old Trafford, overturning a two-goal deficit to secure a 3-2 victory and bring their nine-match winless sequence to an end.
The result was particularly significant because another failure to win would have taken the club to 10 consecutive matches without victory for the first time in more than 40 years.
Roma appeared to be heading towards a comfortable evening after scoring twice within the opening 18 minutes. Their early dominance further frustrated supporters already unhappy with United’s recent performances.
Boos rang around Old Trafford, while some supporters threw tennis balls onto the pitch as the home side struggled to respond.
United eventually changed the direction of the contest. Fernandes reduced the deficit from the penalty spot before Matheus Cunha struck twice late in the match to complete the turnaround.
Fernandes rejects claims that players rescued Carrick
The victory arrived at a sensitive moment for Carrick, whose future had attracted attention following United’s disappointing 3-0 loss to Bournemouth.
Speculation about the manager’s relationship with Fernandes also intensified after the midfielder was dropped from the starting line-up.
Fernandes had publicly questioned the team’s approach following a 4-1 defeat to Como four days earlier. His subsequent absence prompted suggestions that the decision was connected to those comments.
However, the Portuguese international insisted that the situation between himself and Carrick had been misrepresented.
“We don’t need to save anyone’s job,” Fernandes said after the Roma victory.
He explained that the players had been working to improve the club’s situation rather than concentrating on protecting an individual.
“We’ve been working so hard to get out of this situation altogether. It’s been tough. There’s been a lot of speculation in the media, a lot of lies around many things that have happened in this club. Between me and the manager, that we had to clear the air. Nothing like that happened.”
The United captain also defended Carrick’s decision to leave him on the bench, acknowledging that his own performances had not reached the required standard.
“The manager took a decision of putting myself on the bench because I wasn’t performing at that level. Everyone felt that it was a punishment for the words that I had. If it was, it was right.”
Fernandes said he remained committed to the manager’s plans despite accepting that selection decisions were beyond his control.
“The manager is the one who makes the decisions. I have to accept them, I have to go forward with that. It doesn’t change the belief I have in the manager, in the staff and every player that is in this club. It doesn’t change my aim to win every game that I have ahead of me. It should be [a turning point].”
Carrick highlights character after United’s recovery
For Carrick, the result represented an important response from a team that had endured criticism and disappointing performances in recent weeks.
The manager was asked whether the comeback could alter the discussion surrounding his position. He chose to emphasise what the result meant to the club collectively.
“It’s a win for us as a football club,” Carrick said.
He praised the players for refusing to surrender after Roma established their early advantage, explaining that difficult circumstances had revealed important qualities within the squad.
“We’ve shown a lot of character as a group to weather what we’ve had to. You find out a lot about each other, the players will find out things about me. I certainly do about them and their character and what it means to them and what they’re prepared to put in.”
Carrick reserved particular praise for the players who contributed to the recovery, describing their response as deserving of recognition.
“Proud of a lot of people actually, proud of the players, and they deserve a lot of credit for pulling through that in a tough situation.”
The manager also recognised the importance of the supporters’ contribution, especially after the frustration that accompanied United’s difficult opening period.
“And for the supporters, to be there, they were desperate for us to give them something they could get their teeth into.”
He added: “It is really important for the players to know what this place can do.”
Although the victory offered encouragement, Carrick was unwilling to treat one successful evening as proof that United had completely overcome their problems.
“I am not getting too carried away with things but it is an important night,” he said.
Rooney credits Carrick’s half-time intervention
Former Manchester United forward Wayne Rooney also acknowledged the manager’s contribution to the dramatic turnaround.
Rooney pointed out that Carrick faced a difficult situation after his team conceded twice early in the game, but believed the manager’s response helped restore confidence among the players.
“Michael Carrick deserves a lot of credit as well because if you were in his shoes you are thinking, ‘how can I change this around?’”
He suggested that the message delivered during the interval played an important role in United’s improved second-half performance.
“Whatever he said to the team at half-time got them on the front foot and gave them the belief that they could win the game.”
Rooney further described the growing unity between the players and supporters as United moved closer to completing the comeback.
“You felt it, you could feel that they could win the game, everyone was together.”
Roma victory must become a starting point
United’s recovery also revived memories of their 3-2 comeback against Newcastle United in 2018, when they overturned a two-goal deficit under former manager José Mourinho.
Anthony Martial and Alexis Sanchez scored as United recovered from a difficult start to win that encounter at Old Trafford.
However, the victory did not ultimately secure Mourinho’s future. He was dismissed in December, demonstrating that one dramatic result cannot necessarily resolve deeper problems within a football club.
Before the Newcastle match, United had managed only three victories in their previous 10 games. Across the following 13 matches, they recorded five wins, four draws and four defeats.
That history provides a reminder that Carrick’s immediate challenge extends beyond celebrating the Roma result. United must now demonstrate that their improved performance can be sustained.
Their next assignment is against Aston Villa on Sunday, November 8, with the match scheduled to begin at 4:30pm.
Villa, under Unai Emery, will provide another demanding examination of United’s progress. A victory would strengthen the confidence generated at Old Trafford and give Carrick another opportunity to ease concerns about the team’s direction.
The Manchester United comeback against Roma has restored some optimism, but the club’s next performances will determine whether the result represents a genuine change in fortunes or simply a memorable night.
About The Author
